| Priest |
Time of Service |
| Rev. William Bostick |
1860-1864 |
| Rev. James W. Coe |
1864-1869 |
| Vacant |
1869-1883 |
| Rev. Jesse B. Harrison |
1883-1885 |
| Rev. G.W.G. Van Winkle |
1885-1887
Became a mission 1886 |
| Rev. Howard MacDougall |
October 1887 to April 1889 |
| Vacant |
April 1889 to April 1890 |
| Rev. William Gile |
April 1890 to May 1891 |
| Rev. Edmond Phares |
1892-1902 |
| Rev. William Tomlins |
1902-1903 |
| Vacant |
1903-1905 |
| Rev. Henry W. Harris |
1905-1907 |
| Vacant |
1907-1912 |
| Rev. John C. Anderson |
1912-1916 |
| Rev. Thomas Dyke |
1916-1918 |
| Rev. Alexander J.D. Keuhn |
1918-1920 |
| Vacant |
1920-1928 |
| Rev. Grant Kanuff |
1928-1929 |
| Rev. Andrew O. Dodge |
1929-1930 |
| Rev. Simeon Horne Williams |
1930 |
| Rev. Paul C. Shuart |
August 1930 to October 1931 |
| Rev. Thomas A. Dixon |
November 1931 to January 1935 |
| Rev. Ralph Markey |
February 1935 to 1939 |
| Vacant |
1939-1942 |
| Rev. Samuel L. Hagen |
1942-1947 |
| Rev. Gregory A.E. Rowley |
May 1947 to March 1948 |
| Rev. William C. Cowles |
May 1948to October 1950 |
| Rev. Walter John Harris |
October 1950 to July 1956 |
| Rev. Thomas N. Lyons |
July 1956 to January 1959 |
| Vacant |
January 1959 to June 1960 |
Rev. Donald Lee Bell
(First Full-time vicar) |
June 1960 to October 1961 |
| Rev. Walter John Harris |
Octobr 1961 to ebruary 1963 |
| Rev. Fred L. Norman |
February 1963 to May 1964 |
| Rev. Ronald W. Hallett |
July 1964 to November 1964 |
| Rev. Albert W. Hillestad |
November 1964 to May 1965 |
Rev. Carlyle H. Meacham
(Second full-tie vicar) |
June 1965 to May 1966 |
Rev. Thomas L. Phillips
(Third full-time vicar) |
June 1966 to June 1968 |
| Rev. Benjamin Hunter |
July 1968 to August 1971 |
| Rev. J.P. Meyer |
September 1971 to August 1972 |
| Rev. Thomas L. Phillips |
August 1972 to closing of mission |
Note: I believe the mission was closed circa 1976-77, as 12 communicants were reported in 1976 but Anna is not listed in the 1977 Centennial of the diocese booklet. LH